Review of The Thing from Another World (1951) by Calvin C — 31 Dec 2008
Unfortunately for this film the remake completely overshadows it in every imaginable way. Though the plot and events are rather similar John Carpenter's version is truly terrifying. He made the most of the isolated setting, here however it is never fully capitalized on.
The monster is also not very effective. In some shot it is laughable. The explanation of it being a vegetable is no better and we also have the most unrealistic and annoying scientist character I've ever seen.
When the monster and scientist are not on screen there are great character moments thanks to the realistic and endearing dialogue. People talk as though they know each other and there is also an abundance of funny quips.
For fans of 50's Sci-Fi, but if you want real terror, watch the remake.
This review of The Thing from Another World (1951) was written by Calvin C on 31 Dec 2008.
The Thing from Another World has generally received positive reviews.
Was this review helpful?
