Review of The Proposition (2005) by Will K — 01 Jul 2008

I had a passing interest in seeing this movie for some time but had never gotten around to it. I finally rented it mainly because I found out its director was doing the upcoming adaptation of Cormac McCarthy's The Road.

Naturally, I wanted to make sure he was gonna do right by one of the best books I've ever read. I can safely say that not only has my anticipation for that film increased 10-fold, but a new film may well have cracked my top 10.

The Proposition is absolutely stunning from top to bottom. The story of an outlaw who has 9 days to find and kill his older brother in order to save his younger brother from the noose, the film flawlessly brings its unique and compelling premise to life.

Every actor rises to the occasion for the outstanding script. Guy Pearce resonates quiet intensity throughout and brilliantly conveys his character's conflicted position. Despite his character's unrepentant evil, Danny Huston finds in him a surprisingly likable, almost child-like, demeanor.

Ray Winstone, who I've always considered to be a bit one-dimensional, gives a very subtle performance as a (for him) decent man with good intentions and questionable methods. John Hurt is unforgettable in a spectacular cameo.

The score and cinematography provide an incredible atmosphere which perfectly compliments the desolate Australian landscape. It's been nearly a week since I saw this film I have yet to be able to get its many powerful moments out of my mind.

This is an absolutely gripping cinematic experience and I can't recommend it strongly enough.