Review of Gettysburg (1993) by Miles D — 18 Aug 2010

While it might not be as good a representation as some historians and Civil War buffs hoped, Gettysburg is by far the most accurate and pleasing film Hollywood has made about the Civil War. Stunning battle scenes, fabulous performances from its leads, and a beautiful musical score make this Ron Maxwell film a must see for all movie lovers.

The film follows the course of the events taking place from days 1 through 3 of the crucial battle. Everything is present; from the opening shot, too Little Round Top, too Pickett's charge, and finally Lee's retreat. Director Ron Maxwell was especially particular about how the battle scenes took place and he nailed them all, even pinpointing where some commanders were shot! Martin Sheen plays a remarkably stunning Robert E. Lee, presenting the famous General so accurately it could never be duplicated. Jeff Daniels is equally as exquisite and even looks much like the reserved Joshua Chamberlain. Tom Berenger plays Gen. James Longstreet with great conviction, and Stephen Lang portrays George Pickett accurately.

While there are many moments of shine and praise in Gettysburg, there are still a few things to caution for the average moviegoer. The film is extraordinarily long (requiring two sides in the DVD format), and contains so many characters that many will be confused or mistaken. Also, the film has several instances where the spoken parts are almost laughable with overdrawn soliloquies and proper English. Some historians criticize the way the characters talk, while director Ron Maxwell points out that the story is based more on the novel by Micheal Shaara entitled Killer Angels than actual historical fact. If the average moviegoer can get over these few speed bumps they are destined to enjoy this wonderfully made historical epic!