Review of The Guernsey Literary & Potato Peel Pie Society (2018) by Kenr — 13 Feb 2019

There’s a children’s book somewhere in this curious title, and as the original story was completed by the author’s niece, Annie Barrows (who happens to be a writer of children’s books) it makes me wonder if this was her Auntie’s original title? Mary Ann Shaffer, sadly died before her book was published, and from comments made by those who have read ‘their’ novel - the film adaption is disappointing. That said, it’s highly likely those who read the book, after seeing the movie, may find the reverse. Books and screenplay adaptations can be, and are, a world apart. On its own merits, this is a highly enjoyable movie - offering fine performances, direction, wonderful locations, superior cinematography and convincing recreation of a past era - though, at times, it comes across as part ‘feature’ movie and part TV show. There’s also a scene where a Bible is rather obviously being used to ‘push’ a modern feminist’s call.

Lead actress Lily James, is like a dream come true - she was the perfect ‘Cinderella’ in ’15, it’s easy to see why she won that part and the accolades. This story is an account of Germany’s brutal occupation of Guernsey from 1940-45, detailing its dramatic impact on a group of families and friends. It’s both a sentimental romantic tale and an examination of the tragedies experienced by all individuals living under siege. From other reviewer’s comments – it might seem certain modern viewers may have perhaps lost the ability to appreciate the effect these times had on long suffering participants - so, some might tend to view certain aspects of this tale with a degree of cynicism. But generally, the majority of audiences should be pleased with the time they spend being entertained by this engaging story.