Review of Synecdoche, New York (2008) by Bruce A — 17 Jun 2010

76.5.

I. General Impression 8.

10.

-2 Confusion is clearly part of the film's intention -- still distracting.

Some very good laughs in the film. Generally not boring, but sometimes because the viewer is trying to figure out what is going on.

II. Actors 8.

Hoffman is superb. 6 points. No explanation needed.

Two points for remainder of cast. Mostly not the fault of the actors. They are caricatures.

III. Visual Appeal 7.

Set is fitting. Dull, drab. Burning home is not convincing, and while it may have been an intentional effect, it is distracting. If it is meant to convey meaning, it was out of place and heavy handed.

IV. Dialogue 9.5.

V. Character Development 7.

The only character developed is the main character. Yes he is self-absorbed. Apparently so is the writer/director.

VI. Artistic Pursuit 9.5.

As a piece of art it is an excellent discussion of the reflection of an artist within a work of art -- and the extreme narcissism that may result from such an endeavor.

VII. Social Value 6.

Perhaps how extraordinarily poor some artists are as parents. Perhaps the uselessness of exclusively searching to understand oneself or seeking to find the truth.

VIII. Genre Value 9.

Drama, but Kaufman's specialty of subgenre where the author/writer/director intrudes and constantly examines himself as reflection in the creator or self-creation of the work. An Escher style genre.

IX. Critical Appeal 6.5.

X. Sales Appeal 6.

Sales were low in comparison to the cost of the film. Artistically, however, the film got festival viewings and respect. It is also a film that deserves multiple viewings.