Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924) by Jess P — 08 Jul 2008

Keaton's true classic - sheer genius.

This review of Sherlock Jr. (1924) was written by Jess P on 08 Jul 2008.

Sherlock Jr. has generally received very positive reviews.

Was this review helpful?

Yes

More reviews of this movie:

More Reviews of Sherlock Jr.

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Blake P (935) on 22 Jul 2016

I can barely run for ten minutes straight without breaking into a miserable sweat, but Buster Keaton could run for ten hours straight and still…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Matt M (2,511) on 26 Dec 2013

Keaton reaches slapstick perfection with his tale of a film projectionist turned amateur sleuth…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Mark P (1,180) on 03 Jan 2018

Stunts galore, slapstick humour and a great acting performance from Buster Keaton…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Arth J (756) on 07 Dec 2018

Keaton's mime art defines the genre at its best, innocently poignant and genuinely heartwarming. Sherlock Jr…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Melvin W (605) on 14 Mar 2014

Buster Keaton was a film-maker of boundless talent and imagination, performing unbelievable stunts and devising ingenious sight gags that carry…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Kenneth Turan (2,323) for Los Angeles Times (12,977) on 28 May 2015

A master of movement and stillness, Keaton developed a comedy style that was as intellectual as it was physical, and this small gem shows us…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Simon D (1,648) on 12 Sep 2015

You might not expect the world greatest detective in the middle of a Buster Keaton silent movie but here he is, although he is apparently Sherlock…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Ben L (1,326) on 01 Oct 2017

Buster Keaton usually gets praise for his superb physical comedy, and commitment to a sight gag…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Michael E (801) on 28 Mar 2018

I'd never watched any real silent films before, because I feared that if I did the film would be outdated in its humor and wouldn't warrant…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Carlos M (2,069) on 31 Jul 2016

A great movie all the more remarkable due to the technique employed and how Keaton could pull off a number of risky stunts without getting…

Read Review

More reviews of this movie

Reviews of Similar Movies

Review of Stalag 17 (1953)

By Michael E (801) on 30 Jul 2009

MANY people will disagree with me, but I just didn't get hooked, I saw the message, I got the idea, but I was just so disappointed on the follow…

Read Review

Review of Manhattan (1979)

By Broyax (884) on 10 Jan 2017

Revoilà Droopy, revoilà Caliméro qui a repris quelques amphètes et/ou sniffé quelques rails et qui se met à soûler tout le monde, à…

Read Review

Review of Training Day (2001)

By Harsh C (266) on 10 Feb 2012

Started off annoying and got ludicrous, but watched it all anyway…

Read Review

Review of Saw (2004)

By Kevinb. (15) on 20 Jul 2006

Uh...first of all...this isnt a horror film...its a snuff film...its not scarey, it just nasty...bad acting and stupid plot...as most snuff…

Read Review

Review of The Most Dangerous Game (1932)

By Naadhira A (15) on 11 Feb 2018

A film about eurocentrism, white superiority and a white man who can defeat a whole island by his impeccable ability to think with white logic…

Read Review

Review of The Apartment (1960)

By The-Lords A (234) on 30 Mar 2013

Can't believe this film won best picture. It was the kind of movie that could have ended at any point, yet it continued to go on, and on, and on…

Read Review

Review of Snatch (2000)

By Michael W (3,003) on 01 Feb 2013

An atrocious comedic drama which glamorizes criminal activity, violence, and almost mind-numbingly pervasive profanity...I had a hard time…

Read Review

Review of Rashomon (1950)

By Hendrick M (18) on 18 Aug 2018

Outdated characters and storyline. This film has reached its expiration date…

Read Review

Review of Psycho (1960)

By Rayman67 (1) on 26 Oct 2019

I watched this movie for the first time recently and this is the most borring movie ive ever seen…

Read Review

Review of Ed Wood (1994)

By Broyax (884) on 03 Jun 2022

Un film-hommage à un tocard ou plutôt en l’occurrence au roi des tocards puisqu’il fut élu -à titre posthume certes- le « worst director…

Read Review

More Reviews

Popular Movies Right Now

Split

2017

71%1,218 Reviews

War for the Planet of the Apes

2017

78%1,656 Reviews

Dune

2021

77%276 Reviews

Barbarian

2022

72%115 Reviews

Deadpool

2016

78%1,333 Reviews

Inside Out

2015

86%1,276 Reviews

The Judge

2014

67%866 Reviews

Spider-Man: No Way Home

2021

79%458 Reviews

Everything Everywhere All at Once

2022

78%291 Reviews

Talk to Me

2023

74%83 Reviews

Movies You Viewed Recently

Sherlock Jr.

1924

85%302 Reviews

Under the Gun

2016

55%34 Reviews

Prancer Returns

2001

51%5 Reviews

Closer

2013

71%713 Reviews

Gone Girl

2014

81%1,229 Reviews

Go Goa Gone

2013

53%35 Reviews

Major League II

1994

52%268 Reviews

Teeth

2000

57%599 Reviews

Mulk

2018

67%12 Reviews

Captain Corelli's Mandolin

2001

55%506 Reviews