Review of Once Upon a Time in the West (1968) by Robert R — 05 Dec 2017
A masterfully made, if frustratingly imperfect epic that starts out with some of the best things that filmmaking has to offer, furthers its plot with some elements that represent more of a mixed bag, and finishes with - again - some of the best things that filmmaking has to offer.
It's supremely well-made from a cinematographic standpoint. Every shot feels like the threads of a suit that's been tailor made. It's impeccably scored, featuring a bevy of memorable cues for each noteworthy character.
It's got an incredible filmmaker behind its camera, without a shadow of a doubt. But there are some other, rather questionable elements to the film - particularly concerning Claudia Cardinale's character - that don't really age that well, and a plot that wavers into convoluted territory within the second act.
Definitely a fantastically made film, with a really strong opening and finish, but one that - for me - also possessed a flawed middle portion.
This review of Once Upon a Time in the West (1968) was written by Robert R on 05 Dec 2017.
Once Upon a Time in the West has generally received very positive reviews.
Was this review helpful?
