Review of I Think We're Alone Now (2008) by John G — 18 Sep 2008

Walking a fine line between exploiting its subjects and casting a light on the psychological process that leads to celebrity stalking, this documentary is equal parts a disturbing expose and a heart-wrenching examination of delusional behavior.

Turner and McCormick are as different as night and day, but both reveal an unsettling fascination with the singer, as well as a troubling disconnect with reality. Turner, an asperger?s syndrome sufferer, is friendly and intelligent, but also a delusional liar and braggart.

McCormick, a transexual lesbian?a man living as a lesbian woman, has a psyche fractured long ago by her parents, and an insecurity that hovers too closely to inner rage for comfort. There are many unforgettable moments in the film, like Turner?s trip to the Glamorcon, a porno model convention, and his subsequent church testimony on the subject, along with his theory on Alyssa Milano?s time traveling ability.

McCormick?s moments are more subtle, like watching her frustration as she applies and re-applies make-up for her first meeting with Tiffany, or the moment she snaps at Turner when he talks about his connection with the singer.