Review of A Very Long Engagement (2004) by Andy S — 22 Apr 2009

I am certainly not the first film critique to try to make some connection between the title of this film and the fact that this is an interminably long film (a VERY long engagement indeed!). I cannot argue that this is a beautifully shot film with a wonderful early 20th century color palette. As a piece of visual art, the film is as stunning as Jeunet's earlier (and far better) Amelie.

Yet, beneath its compelling cinematography, is a film that seems very lost. The storyline is confusing and convoluted at best. There were some plot turns that resulted in some interesting visuals, but weren't exactly necessary to support the plot or advance the story. I suppose, however, there is something to be said for little vignettes in life. Truthfully, how often are our own stories told in a straight line resulting in a complete understanding of the events that have or are unfolding?

Still, a director must be conscious of one's audience and do what he/she can to deliver an honest story with some semblance of a point (am I being too unrealistic about film here?). The resolution of this film did not leave me very engaged. Perhaps better said, I was ambivalent concerning whether or not the protagonists reunited and I doubt this is the particular emotion the film's creators intended to produce.