Review of A Star Is Born (1954) by Peggy L — 24 Sep 2007

My favorite Judy Garland flick She was robbed of a well deserved Oscar. Far outshone all the other Oscar nominees.

This review of A Star Is Born (1954) was written by Peggy L on 24 Sep 2007.

A Star Is Born has generally received very positive reviews.

Was this review helpful?

Yes

More reviews of this movie:

A Star Is Born (1954) Movie Reviews (285)
A Star Is Born (1954) Critic Reviews (16)
A Star Is Born (1954) User Reviews (269)

More Reviews of A Star Is Born

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Scott F (708) on 10 Oct 2015

THE best version ever made, when released the theateres complained about its over 3 hr running time, so it was cut to shreds and that is why…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Les E (496) on 22 May 2014

Garland and Mason were both amazing stars and here they are being amazing together. Still not too long even at almost three hours…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Logan M (1,902) on 03 Jul 2017

Every scene, every song, every piece of set design is sensational and Judy Garland is exceptionally stunning in the lead of this showbiz classic…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Matt H (2,287) on 18 Aug 2013

Possibly the most adapted storyline…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Paul D (6,077) on 14 May 2015

Hollywood turns on itself as a subtle critic of the star system within the money-mad entertainment world of Los Angeles…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Augustine H (906) on 04 Aug 2013

Honestly, I have never really enjoyed this film until James Mason's breakdown…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Mark L (1,544) on 09 Jun 2014

I never saw Grace Kelly in The Country Girl, but she must have been pretty dog gone good if she beat the uncanny performance by Garland in…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Greg W (4,011) on 28 Jan 2014

A perfect comeback vehicle for Judy the songs r awesome plus technicolour and stereophonic sound…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Calum B (434) on 18 Aug 2013

Possibly the most adapted storyline…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Harry W (1,900) on 23 May 2013

The actual viewing pleasure of A Star is Born is damaged due to the loss of much of the film's original footage and the fact that it attempts…

Read Review

More reviews of this movie

Reviews of Similar Movies

Review of Two for the Road (1967)

By Ross P (247) on 03 Sep 2009

The idea should be great, to chronicle the love story and marriage of a couple by their travels around Europe, showing the different stages…

Read Review

Review of The Mexican (2001)

By Jim Judy (1,199) for Screen It! (1,437) on 14 Mar 2001

A mostly entertaining production that's certainly easy to watch thanks to the presence of its three stars and their lively and fun performances…

Read Review

Review of Papillon (1973)

By Dale K (28) on 06 Oct 2016

I love both Dustin and Steve but this movie failed to keep me engaged, didn't finish watching the whole movie…

Read Review

Review of Kiss of Death (1995)

By Stephen L (620) on 22 Apr 2015

There's good over the top Cage then there is this slop,add in thinking this is the star vehicle Caruso left NYPD Blue for and this bomb is lit…

Read Review

More Reviews

Popular Movies Right Now

Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood

2019

81%344 Reviews

Split

2017

71%1,218 Reviews

A Simple Favor

2018

69%617 Reviews

The Batman

2022

75%430 Reviews

Hereditary

2018

72%1,650 Reviews

No Hard Feelings

2023

65%90 Reviews

War for the Planet of the Apes

2017

78%1,656 Reviews

The Prodigy

2019

53%39 Reviews

Gone Girl

2014

81%1,229 Reviews

Logan

2017

82%1,785 Reviews

Movies You Viewed Recently

A Star Is Born

1954

80%285 Reviews

Mr. Holland's Opus

1995

69%535 Reviews

Tortured

2008

53%70 Reviews

Stage Beauty

2004

68%410 Reviews

A Day Off

1968

78%209 Reviews

Marry Me

2022

65%85 Reviews

I've Loved You So Long

2008

77%642 Reviews

Sense and Sensibility

1995

81%553 Reviews

Fight Club: Members Only

2006

53%36 Reviews

Lost in Translation

2003

80%1,069 Reviews