Review of Young Sherlock Holmes (1985) by Dennis L — 01 May 2008

Young Sherlock Holmes weaves an amusing speculative tale of the great detective's early years. It presumes that Sherlock Holmes and John Watson met while they were still studying. With the help of Elizabeth, the niece of an eccentric professor and the love of Holme's life, the trio investigates the death of prominent Englishmen which appears to be caused by horrible hallucinations. Their investigation leads them to an evil Egyptian sect seeking revenge.

While we have our modern day forensics heroes like Grissom, Horatio Caine, etc., back in the 80s, the most popular forensics hero was still Sherlock Holmes.

I remember watching this movie in 1985 and enjoying it tremendously. Having read almost all of the Sherlock Holmes short stories by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, I was fascinated by old school forensic science. The movie goes on to explain how Holmes started with his pipe, his hat and his cape.

Now 23 years later, I'm afraid the movie has lost some of its luster and appeal. I guess growing up has its disadvantages hehe. While the production was fresh and exciting during that time, the movie looked a bit passe already. The story is still well written though it didn't hold any surprises anymore since I already knew it. So its watchability is greatly diminished on the 2nd viewing.

Nevertheless, Young Sherlock Holmes and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's short stories are a must for youngsters. It's a great entertaining adolescent read and should help your kids appreciate great literature.

Story: 7/10.

Boredom Factor: 4/10 (more if you already know the story).

Pace: Medium.

Watch Again Rating: 3/10.

Talk to Action Ratio: 7:3.

Overall: 6/10.