Review of The Pledge (2001) by Steve V — 29 Oct 2009

Throughout our lives we hope and search for convenient and satisfyingly happy conclusions, all wrapped up in a pretty pink bow and sprinkled with just the right amount of certainty...sadly however, more often than not, fate doesn't play by the rules and that, in essence, is what gives Sean Penn's 'The Pledge' it's power. The subject matter is confronting and its characters flawed, but the story is one many of us will relate to. Jerry Black (Jack Nicholson), as the retired detective who is indebted to solve one last harrowing murder, is a well meaning, compassionate and resolute being who?s one damning flaw is that he is searching for righteousness in an imperfect world. Penn?s menacing and morose direction is effective in its contrast with the bright and beautiful landscapes that act as the backdrop to Jerry?s investigation )and his eventual decent into hopelessness). A mostly impressive supporting cast, (the almost always brilliant Benicio del Toro just doesn?t quite work for me in his role), help to cement the stark realism and Nicholson?s tortured performance is profoundly captivating.

As hard going as it can be I still recommend a second viewing of this movie to really appreciate its value and it will allow you to see some of the events from a different perspective, don?t throw this movie back in one uncomfortable gulp, savour it, let it wash around your mind for a while and it?s melancholic hangover will stay with you for a long time as will the many questions it poses. (Also look out for a brief but hypnotic turn by Mickey Rourke.).

Ben Edmonds 30/10/09.