Review of The Giver (2014) by Aslanmane — 11 Sep 2014

I loved reading the book in high school, college and after college. However, this is not the film that this novel was meant for. I can't believe I will write this, but I wish Aaron Sorkin wrote the screenplay. This is a very philosophical, and propagandist material and Sorkin's preaching from the pulpit of high-minded idealism approach to all of his work would work wonders.

The early parts of the film were a very close adaptation of the film, and was the peak of its engagement with its audience. The graduation ceremony was perfect; it was flashy, current and a spectacle. After that, it slowly descends into hollywood tropes and lazy retrofitting for a modern audience.

All of the scenes with Jonas and the Giver were wonderfully adapted. Jeff Bridges was more than adequate as the Giver. Meryl Streep's character was very strange. She was created to add conflict, which is understandable. However, in the context of the film's universe, she is a paradox. She has as much knowledge as the receiver of memories and she has emotions. That's a big plot hole and a mistake. Asher, Jonas' friend lied to an elder. Another plot hole and mistake. The sameness applies to all members of the community. In trying to make the film more appealing to action-adventure crowds, it has really destroyed the character of the source material.

I wish it were written better. Everything about this film was excellent, apart from the screenplay.