Review of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (2008) by Russell G — 15 Jun 2014

Growing younger and going against the natural order is an extremely compelling concept. It also holds great potential for an unconventional but beautiful love story. This is a well-made movie, but the story is often sad and hollow, even somewhat tragic.

Like any life story, it is full of high points and low points, but it is lonelier than most. At no point does it establish any lasting friendships or relationships. This of course is the tragedy of going through life backwards, but I wish there was more beauty in it as well.

It does achieve a fine poetic commentary on the processes and different stages of life, yet it is not fulfilling on an emotional level. I like the retrospective perspective, and interesting storytelling technique comes from alternating between the present and a collection of flashbacks.

David Fincher has matured into a talented director, and it shows here. The changing times read clearly at each step, and the settings and backgrounds reflect and enhance the mood in a positive way. Most of the cast is good, but Kate Blanchet comes across as cold and harsh, even when she does not intend to.

I think this would be stronger with a lead female actor who has more warmth and life in her.