Review of The Boondock Saints II: All Saints Day (2009) by Tristan L — 08 Dec 2013

I really don't understand the critic's hate for this movie (the franchise as a whole.) The movie doesn't boast great acting and the story isn't complex, but the movie is quite unique and enjoyable. Many compare it to Tarantino's work, and it's obvious it was inspired by it, but I think The Boondock Saints carved something all its own.

The Boondock Saints II has a lot of good going for it: the brothers are likable and have chemistry together, there is lots of funny (though uneven) dialogue, a great soundtrack, and stylish action sequences.

Duffy did a great job of duplicating what what successful in The Boondock Saints, yet didn't stick to it religiously (this isn't a Hangover/Hangover 2 situation) There is obvious mirroring going on with the inclusion of a sidekick, the overly-dramatic special agent, etc. but it wasn't overly distracting.

I think the introduction of a secondary plot involving Poppa M's backstory was pretty cool. Again, the acting and plot is isn't very strong, but it's passable. I really think Duffy improved his directing int this. Benz, rather than Dafoe, is the main reason this movie isn't as good as the original. Benz character is VERY annoying.

I love that it makes several references to the original, even bring back Rocco in a dream sequence. I also really liked Romeo. It will be fun to see if they carry out the formula they have established so far in the franchise and added another sidekick in the sequel.

In all, I definitely recommend, especially if you (unlike the critics) enjoyed the original. It's not as good, but close, and is a worthy sequel.