Cinafilm has over 5 million movie reviews and counting …
Sitemap
Search

Last updated: 09 Jun 2026 at 14:24 UTC

Back to movie details

Review of by Frank P — 05 Jul 2017

Share
Tweet

*** SQUEEKY-CLEAN SOFT PORN, COSTUME PSYCHO-THRILLER***.

I'm assuming the Civil War had a profound effect on most people's lives in the Confederate South, since the war began in April 1861, ending in May 1865. [What do I know? I only know what little I've read since high school, magazines and watching Ken Burns' Civil War series on PBS]. Except for The Beguiled's movie set(s), a locked iron gate, overgrown vegetation surrounding an old antebellum mansion [girl's boarding school], the interior movie sets/decorations/costumes did not seem to account for the effects of the Civil War [1864]... Behind the front doors of the mansion, for example, there were plentiful furnishings, beautiful clothes for every person and every occasion, chandeliers, candelabras, tall candles, abundant food and wines; everything one would need in case of a natural disaster... This seemed to be slightly unrealistic and unfathomable for 1864, but so was the depiction of the Confederate South in the movie, Gone With The Wind [so they say]. In any event, my common sense tells me that The Beguiled is no less than a sterile, overly-starched "costume" drama. What my movie ticket really bought was, a 21st-century kaleidoscope gaze at Nicole Kidman, Kirsten Dunst and Colin Farrell in Civil War couture... I got to see how well the actors "looked" and how well they have aged over the last decade; perfect hair, perfect make-up, etc... Their acting abilities were FINE, but The Beguiled is not one of those films one would particularly recommend to a friend, nor own, nor see again. It's obvious that this film is only a showcase for the principal actors, especially for Dunst and Farrell, whom we haven't seen in films, lately. Overall, it's a calling card for Kidman, Dunst and Farrell... It will help them get better jobs and roles in future movies, that's all... One of the things I noticed about this film was, there were so many costume changes. No doubt this was a plan to further the career of the film's costume designer and/or provide Project Runway fans with a Civil War-era fashion show, sans runway... As well, in 95 percent of the movie scenes, the costume garments appeared to be too new [never-been-worn] freshly laundered and, starched up the wazoo... Also, except for a tiny little wound and some bleeding, the characters in The Beguiled rarely had a smudge, nor an ounce of dirt or sweat on them. Come on! Not even when Colin Farrell does a little gardening and tree pruning do we see dirt on his perfectly-ironed man-costume... I'm not looking for clichés of the Civil War, nor am I wanting to see a cast of little match girls or individuals from the Dust Bowl... I just want a little realism, okay? This is a big-budgeted Hollywood-style movie, no doubt.

This review of The Beguiled (2017) was written by on 05 Jul 2017.

The Beguiled has generally received positive reviews.

Was this review helpful?

Yes
No

More Reviews of The Beguiled

More reviews of this movie

Share This Page

Share
Tweet

Popular Movies Right Now

Movies You Viewed Recently

Get social with CinafilmFollow us for reviews of the latest moviesCinafilm - TwitterCinafilm - PinterestCinafilm - RSS