Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924) by Randy T — 29 Sep 2012

Timeless comedy from the genius of Buster Keaton.

This review of Sherlock Jr. (1924) was written by Randy T on 29 Sep 2012.

Sherlock Jr. has generally received very positive reviews.

Was this review helpful?

Yes

More reviews of this movie:

More Reviews of Sherlock Jr.

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Simon D (1,648) on 12 Sep 2015

You might not expect the world greatest detective in the middle of a Buster Keaton silent movie but here he is, although he is apparently Sherlock…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Carreh R (65) on 07 Sep 2014

Boasts impressive visuals for the time and many of the gags hit, but the story meanders more than it should and the film lags in places…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Andrey B (847) on 24 Nov 2016

Amazing masterpiece, it's ubelievable how Keaton performed all those tricks…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Pierluigi P (335) on 10 Aug 2013

Hilarious and physically impressive gags. Keaton's imagination was boundless…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Matt M (2,511) on 26 Dec 2013

Keaton reaches slapstick perfection with his tale of a film projectionist turned amateur sleuth…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Alex S (2,786) on 07 Aug 2014

It may not be as good as The General, but it'll still keep you smiling the whole way through…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Emma Simmonds (380) for Little White Lies (3,136) on 28 May 2015

Sherlock Jr…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By David Parkinson (764) for Empire Magazine (3,326) on 28 May 2015

Buster Keaton's third and shortest feature ranks among his best…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Michael E (801) on 28 Mar 2018

I'd never watched any real silent films before, because I feared that if I did the film would be outdated in its humor and wouldn't warrant…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Blake P (935) on 22 Jul 2016

I can barely run for ten minutes straight without breaking into a miserable sweat, but Buster Keaton could run for ten hours straight and still…

Read Review

More reviews of this movie

Reviews of Similar Movies

Review of Mixed Nuts (1994)

By Christopher Harris (24) for The Globe and Mail (Toronto) (4,018) on 27 Aug 2012

But though there's half a cashew of Steve Martin's amazing physical comedy, a couple of pecans of Sven Nyqvist's beautiful cinematography and…

Read Review

Review of Mr. Deeds Goes to Town (1936)

By Alex K (2,253) on 27 Jul 2013

My Favorite Film Is 1941's Citizen Kane…

Read Review

Review of Mr. & Mrs. Smith (1941)

By Alexander D (349) on 23 Jun 2011

Oh, this is supposed to be a comedy? My mistake…

Read Review

Review of Stan Helsing (2009)

By Robert Abele (1,309) for Los Angeles Times (12,977) on 07 Dec 2009

Like garlic, holy water and silver bullets for our mythic evildoers, Stan Helsing is a surefire repellent to any good time…

Read Review

Review of Open City (2008)

By John A. Nesbit (472) for Old School Reviews (429) on 20 Aug 2001

The rough cinéma vérité appearance achieved in Open City, with its natural lighting and uneven film stock, was more due to economic and…

Read Review

Review of The Tall Guy (1989)

By Tim S (2,419) on 08 Oct 2011

Had its funny moments, few, but they were there. The story line is well…

Read Review

More Reviews

Popular Movies Right Now

Ready Player One

2018

72%1,541 Reviews

The Platform

2019

70%94 Reviews

Ford v Ferrari

2019

81%171 Reviews

Past Lives

2023

84%62 Reviews

Interstellar

2014

83%1,261 Reviews

Babylon

2022

68%144 Reviews

A Quiet Place

2018

76%1,685 Reviews

The Voyeurs

2021

58%19 Reviews

Everything Everywhere All at Once

2022

78%291 Reviews

The Killing of a Sacred Deer

2017

69%660 Reviews

Movies You Viewed Recently

Sherlock Jr.

1924

85%302 Reviews

Stronger

2017

73%381 Reviews

Peter Rabbit

2018

61%470 Reviews

Tombstone

1993

74%622 Reviews

The Counselor

2013

46%904 Reviews

Anonymous

2011

58%750 Reviews

The Rock

1996

74%627 Reviews

Three Kings

2011

66%537 Reviews

You Can Count on Me

2000

80%422 Reviews

The Perfect Guy

2015

52%295 Reviews