Review of Redacted (2007) by Carolyn L — 28 Mar 2008

Horrible story, but excellent movie. you have to watch it to understand.

This review of Redacted (2007) was written by Carolyn L on 28 Mar 2008.

Redacted has generally received mixed reviews.

Was this review helpful?

Yes

More reviews of this movie:

More Reviews of Redacted

Review of Redacted (2007)

By Marjorie Baumgarten (1,950) for Austin Chronicle (7,653) on 17 Nov 2015

Despite its shortcomings, Redacted is nevertheless a film brimming with spontaneity and fury, and in a season of often-ambiguous films about…

Read Review

Review of Redacted (2007)

By Joe Morgenstern (2,395) for Wall Street Journal (3,071) on 27 Aug 2016

The Americans are portrayed with varying degrees of loathsomeness, but there's not much variety in the film. It's all an awful aberration…

Read Review

Review of Redacted (2007)

By Alan W (854) on 31 Oct 2015

It would have been 4 stars but there are some minor quibbles as to how a director as accomplished as De Palma has managed to fail in appropriating…

Read Review

Review of Redacted (2007)

By Zack B (668) on 11 Feb 2013

In many ways it's a necessary film and I admire all involved for making it…

Read Review

Review of Redacted (2007)

By Rick Groen (1,350) for The Globe and Mail (Toronto) (4,018) on 28 Sep 2014

Love it, hate it, but be sure to watch it, because this odd and disturbing picture is as different as the war it reflects, and that difference…

Read Review

Review of Redacted (2007)

By Jérôme M (188) on 21 May 2010

Good movie about a rape and assassination case that happened in Iraq during the war. It reminds a lot another Brian de Palmaâ…

Read Review

Review of Redacted (2007)

By Gianluca C (89) on 30 Oct 2012

Not bad in the same way as the actual occupation of Iraq... but, as far as films go, this is pretty bad…

Read Review

Review of Redacted (2007)

By David Ansen (1,073) for Newsweek (1,534) on 11 Oct 2010

If you're trying to make us believe we're watching reality by using a faux documentary style, you need actors who never look like they are…

Read Review

Review of Redacted (2007)

By Fred P (38) on 08 Jan 2013

I watched Redacted (2007) last night. I was reminded of the movie, Casualties of War (1989), also directed by Brian De Palama…

Read Review

Review of Redacted (2007)

By David Denby (676) for The New Yorker (1,837) on 24 Dec 2016

Redacted is hell to sit through, but I think De Palma is bravely trying to imagine his way inside an atrocity, and that he’s onto something…

Read Review

More reviews of this movie

Reviews of Similar Movies

Review of Gosford Park (2001)

By Jojojo (1) on 20 Nov 2005

I have a high IQ so this movie is great! I have a low self esteem so I'm going to rave about this movie and say how my IQ is better than others here…

Read Review

Review of Gone Baby Gone (2007)

By Msc (2) on 01 Mar 2008

Wow what a HORRIBLE MOVIE!!! Monotone dialogue, cliche story…

Read Review

Review of Jindabyne (2006)

By Moses S (34) on 01 Feb 2009

Too slow.....I turned it off halfway through…

Read Review

Review of Wonderland (2003)

By Robert I (1,833) on 22 Jan 2013

As a drug movie it fails. Which is fine, it never really wanted to be one. As a crime movie it's pretty terrible. Ice Harvest terrible…

Read Review

Review of Obsession (1943)

By Jens T (504) on 04 Jul 2011

Luchino Visconti's Ossessione is the italian adaption of James M. Cain's The Postman Always Rings Twice…

Read Review

Review of Mercy (2000)

By Ralph R (732) on 04 Mar 2008

Lesbians! Cannibalism (sort of)! The randomest scene ever of Ellen Barkin doing it with a Baldwin brother…

Read Review

Review of Masculin Féminin (1966)

By Sherwin L (102) on 21 Aug 2007

Watched part of this for film school ~ really couldn't get into it. fast-forwarded thru most of it…

Read Review

Review of The Hunting Party (2007)

By Aproxx (58) on 13 Aug 2018

I guess there is people for everything. This shouldn't exist. 30' and I had to just stop watching…

Read Review

Review of Final Analysis (1992)

By Bubbajack (2) on 11 Oct 2005

Thumbs down to the Director's Cut. Adding the dream sequence is just as bad as Lucas adding Greedo's arm or Luke's scream…

Read Review

Review of Cassandra's Dream (2007)

By Craigg. (3) on 08 Nov 2008

Quite possibly one of the worst movies I have seen in a long time…

Read Review

More Reviews

Popular Movies Right Now

Bullet Train

2022

66%170 Reviews

Parasite

2019

88%251 Reviews

Dawn of the Planet of the Apes

2014

79%1,167 Reviews

Alien: Covenant

2017

61%1,909 Reviews

Fifty Shades of Grey

2015

43%1,173 Reviews

War for the Planet of the Apes

2017

78%1,656 Reviews

Mission: Impossible - Dead Reckoning Part One

2023

79%186 Reviews

Three Thousand Years of Longing

2022

65%84 Reviews

The Killing of a Sacred Deer

2017

69%660 Reviews

The Judge

2014

67%866 Reviews