Review of Ninotchka (1939) by James H — 13 Jun 2004

(VHS) (First Viewing, 3rd Lubitsch film).

I feel like I've really missed something here. I've read numerous rave reviews, praising [b]Ninotchka[/b]'s wit, style and humor, but I found it distinctly lacking in all three. Even the magnificent Greta Garbo couldn't save this one.

And even she's not all that great. She's perfectly cast as a severe Communist "comrade" sent to Paris to settle a legal dispute, but once she falls in love and her icy reserve begins to melt, the film quickly goes downhill. Of all the things she is, a giddy lovesick girl she is not. She does look great in her crisp parade uniform though.

That said, Garbo's the best thing about the film. I was more put off by the script and story, which suggests that a reserved girl devoted to her moral standards can be instantly swept off her feet by a few slyly romantic words coming from a sophisticated dandy. The whole plot felt awkward, and the absolute worst thing that can occur in a film like this happens- it lacks a romantic spark. No chemistry between the leads, no real romantic tension, not even a really great kiss. Also disappointing that the issue of whether to be true to one's ideals or emotions wasn't dealt with in any type of interesting, let alone meaningful, way.

I'm baffled by this film's huge reputation. For my money, [b]Bluebeard's Eighth Wife[/b], which seems to be one of everybody's least favorite Lubistch films, is superior in every way. See that one to see how delightful and effervescent classic screwball wit and romance is like when it's done right.