Review of My Best Girl (1927) by David S — 23 Jun 2012

Charming silent romantic comedy that botches its last fifteen minutes by going on way too long.

This review of My Best Girl (1927) was written by David S on 23 Jun 2012.

My Best Girl has generally received very positive reviews.

Was this review helpful?

Yes

More reviews of this movie:

More Reviews of My Best Girl

Review of My Best Girl (1927)

By Angela P (262) on 13 Apr 2008

Really great movie, the perfect one for Mary Pickford to do as her last silent film. Mary and Buddy were a really terrific pair…

Read Review

Review of My Best Girl (1927)

By Debbie P (191) on 23 Mar 2007

My Best Girl is from 1927 and was Mary Pickford's last silent movie. Mary starred opposite her third husband Buddy Rogers…

Read Review

Review of My Best Girl (1927)

By Z P (29) on 29 Jun 2008

This was a really cute story, but it was kind of odd, because what I thought it was done there was still 1/2 hour left…

Read Review

Review of My Best Girl (1927)

By Aj V (1,538) on 07 Dec 2010

Although the romance in the film is as predictable as ever, this movie has charm and humor, and great actors. I really enjoyed it and I recommend it…

Read Review

Review of My Best Girl (1927)

By Private U (13,627) on 10 Jun 2007

This was my first silent film experience. it's so charming, I love it…

Read Review

Review of My Best Girl (1927)

By Joel A (1,152) on 07 Aug 2012

Mary Pickford's final silent film before her unsuccessful foray into early talkies, and what a film to go out on…

Read Review

Review of My Best Girl (1927)

By Austin L (160) on 31 May 2007

This is definitely my favorite silent film. In fact, this is the movie that made me fall in love with Pickford and her work…

Read Review

Review of My Best Girl (1927)

By Lauren Q (13) on 17 Jan 2008

What a great silent film! Very, very entertaining! It was like a version of Cinderella only better. You see it…

Read Review

Review of My Best Girl (1927)

By Bruce B (1,130) on 21 Nov 2008

My Best Girl directed by Sam Taylor written by Allen McNeil, Tim Whelan adapted for the screen by Hope Loring story by Kathleen Norris starring…

Read Review

Review of My Best Girl (1927)

By Stella P (4) on 03 Nov 2007

Classic story done really really well. Unbelievably romantic…

Read Review

More reviews of this movie

Reviews of Similar Movies

Review of The Gold Rush (1925)

By Paul A (1,065) on 24 Mar 2011

Some parts were funny but for the most part it was dull and boring…

Read Review

Review of The Manxman (1929)

By Matt C (2,668) on 11 Jun 2015

Alas! This is not Alfred Hitchcock's take on the Mark Cavendish story, Britain's greatest ever cycling sprinter…

Read Review

Review of Limite (1931)

By Carlos M (2,069) on 26 Aug 2013

This film is a great, poetic, inspiring mystery ride…

Read Review

Review of Bear (1993)

By Sloan Freer (34) for Radio Times (2,421) on 02 Jun 2010

A vengeful bear has more screen presence than his human victims in this feeble man-against-nature tale…

Read Review

More Reviews

Popular Movies Right Now

Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood

2019

81%344 Reviews

No Time to Die

2021

74%254 Reviews

Three Thousand Years of Longing

2022

65%84 Reviews

Love

2015

54%174 Reviews

Dark Waters

2019

76%68 Reviews

Hillbilly Elegy

2020

61%141 Reviews

The Voyeurs

2021

58%19 Reviews

Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse

2023

85%233 Reviews

Hereditary

2018

72%1,650 Reviews

Ford v Ferrari

2019

81%171 Reviews

Movies You Viewed Recently

My Best Girl

1927

77%15 Reviews

The 'Burbs

1989

65%674 Reviews

Boyhood

2014

81%1,256 Reviews

Afternoon Delight

2013

53%134 Reviews

Guzaarish

2010

72%111 Reviews

Captain America: The First Avenger

2011

69%1,267 Reviews

Mixed Nuts

1994

42%236 Reviews

Children of the Corn 666: Isaac's Return

1999

37%53 Reviews

Fantasia

2015

69%632 Reviews

Moonlight and Valentino

1995

55%49 Reviews