Murder by Decree (1979) - User Reviews - Page 2 of 4

21-40 of 61 Reviews

Sort by:

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Scott T (380) on 16 Mar 2010

Very well done Sherlock Holmes film in which Holmes pursues Jack the Ripper and uncovers a deeper scandal reaching perhaps to the British throne…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Debbie W (184) on 21 Feb 2010

The idea behind this film is Sherlock Holmes, played brilliantly by Christopher Plummer, and Doctor Watson played by the amazing oh so sad…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Daniel C (1,809) on 13 Feb 2010

Not really that good. Both From Hell and Sherlock Holmes are, inexplicably, much better…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By James B (2,746) on 02 Jan 2010

Disappointed! Great story idea, excellent cast, especially with Plummer as Holmes…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By David P (1,645) on 01 Dec 2009

Terrific tale about Sherlock Holmes going after Jack the Ripper! AMAZING cast handled well by director Bob Clark (A Christmas Story)…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Frank H (420) on 19 Nov 2009

It was about as good as non-canonical Holmes gets…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Jason G (1,003) on 20 Jun 2009

An overly complex story that didn't really make sense in the end. Reasonable acting but not reasonable for the period…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Alexander A (393) on 03 Jun 2009

Great performances, especially from James Mason and a very creepy tone I was not expecting. Also From Hell might owe these guys a check…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Genevieve P (47) on 24 Mar 2009

J'ai eu l'impression de revivre mes annees de jeunesse, quand je regardais des films l'apres-midi, les jours de semaine, pour passer le temps…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Jean-Marie L (67) on 22 Nov 2008

I usually find sherlock movies more of a parody of itself half the time…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Paul T (570) on 17 Sep 2008

If you've seen the Hughes Brother's Ripper tale and Johnny Depp starrer 'From Hell', then you're going to think you have deja vu when you see…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Bojan B (5) on 29 Aug 2008

How can someone resist confrontation between Sherlock Holmes and Jack the Ripper…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Karsh D (1,216) on 10 Aug 2008

Some good bits -some poor bits - the summing up at the end goes on a bit and would have liked to have seen more of Jack The Ripper - from a…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Paul C (2,626) on 07 Aug 2008

Intelligent take on the Jack The Ripper story this time pitting the world's greatest detective against him…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Paul D (6,077) on 06 Aug 2008

More of a Holmes story than a Ripper one, it is nicely woven together, but lacks the punch of the themes and plots it tries to merge…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Trevor R (511) on 19 Jul 2008

Well done Holmes meets Jack the Ripper yarn by consummate genre-hopper Bob Clark. Fantastic cast! Great chemistry between Plummer and Mason…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Shannon S (416) on 28 Jun 2008

Amazing cinematography! Great story-telling! Also, a fascinating solution to a mystery no one has ever solved... dun dun dun…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Michael T (3,420) on 07 Jun 2008

Bob Clark's last film before he directed PORKY'S (1982) was also his best. Sherlock Holmes versus Saucy Jack…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By François D (136) on 29 May 2008

The inspiration for From Hell. Excellent movie, well acted and produced…

Read Review

Review of Murder by Decree (1979)

By Kevin (114) on 15 May 2008

You just THINK they don't know who The Ripper was…

Read Review

Page 2 of 4

More reviews of this movie:

More from the same director:

Rhinestone

1984

40%122 Reviews

A Christmas Story

1983

80%658 Reviews

Baby Geniuses

1999

25%423 Reviews

More Thriller Movies from 1979:

When a Stranger Calls

1979

59%439 Reviews

I... for Icarus

1979

81%10 Reviews

Cuba

1979

46%19 Reviews

More Crime Movies from 1979:

Scum

1979

79%259 Reviews

Survival Run

1979

30%2 Reviews

Murder by Natural Causes

1979

81%3 Reviews

More Mystery Movies from 1979:

The Double McGuffin

1979

58%3 Reviews

The Butterfly Murders

1979

64%7 Reviews

Bear Island

1979

48%8 Reviews

Movies you might like:

The Lodger: A Story of the London Fog

1927

73%113 Reviews

The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

1939

73%56 Reviews

Terror by Night

1946

64%35 Reviews

The Pearl of Death

1944

73%22 Reviews

From Hell

2001

61%672 Reviews

Sherlock Holmes and the Baker Street Irregulars

2007

61%5 Reviews

The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes

1970

70%119 Reviews

Enola Holmes 2

2022

67%64 Reviews

Sherlock Holmes in Washington

1943

61%14 Reviews

The Scarlet Claw

1944

71%27 Reviews

Tom and Jerry Meet Sherlock Holmes

2010

61%8 Reviews