Review of Mistress America (2015) by Mad M — 14 Nov 2015

Decent premise, poorly executed. The dialogue is unrealistic and Gerwig's character feels very fake.

This review of Mistress America (2015) was written by Mad M on 14 Nov 2015.

Mistress America has generally received positive reviews.

Was this review helpful?

Yes

More reviews of this movie:

Mistress America (2015) Movie Reviews (328)
Mistress America (2015) Critic Reviews (151)
Mistress America (2015) User Reviews (177)

More Reviews of Mistress America

Review of Mistress America (2015)

By Brad S (2,657) on 10 Jan 2017

1st of two Baumbach's that I saw back to back. Once again it is talky and interesting for no particular reason. Charming…

Read Review

Review of Mistress America (2015)

By Peter F (998) on 15 Jul 2016

Yes, Noah Baumbach is releasing a second film this year, but fortunately it's much more of a delight than the underwhelming While We're Young…

Read Review

Review of Mistress America (2015)

By John935 (47) on 28 May 2016

Ok, so I give this a 7, meaning not the greatest thing since French toast but I like it, I really like it…

Read Review

Review of Mistress America (2015)

By A.d. O (421) on 13 Aug 2016

A really quirky comedy that is worth checking out…

Read Review

Review of Mistress America (2015)

By Matt Wolf (69) for The Arts Desk (640) on 21 Nov 2017

This short film (less than 90 minutes) starts out entertainingly enough but soon wears out its welcome on the way to an ending suggesting Baumbach…

Read Review

Review of Mistress America (2015)

By Johannes J (261) on 08 Jul 2016

Pretentious and over the top acting at times, this film was both sweet and dreadful at the same time…

Read Review

Review of Mistress America (2015)

By Nickthecritick (243) on 03 Nov 2021

Tracy Fishko, a college freshman, has moved to New York City and left behind a deceased father and a mother who is about to remarry…

Read Review

Review of Mistress America (2015)

By Farah R (1,015) on 31 Aug 2016

Not sure if anyone in this movie was supposed to have good qualities but I still felt something after watching it…

Read Review

Review of Mistress America (2015)

By Mark J (665) on 29 Aug 2018

I like Greta Gerwig. I didnt like her in this though…

Read Review

Review of Mistress America (2015)

By Jerry M (80) on 23 Aug 2016

Noah Baumbach directs yet another aimless and boring coming of age privileged New York hipster movie populated with annoying, whiny, unlikable,…

Read Review

More reviews of this movie

Reviews of Similar Movies

Review of Princess Protection Program (2009)

By Tionne C (8) on 09 Nov 2012

I love demi and selena, but I hate this movie…

Read Review

Review of Jawbreaker (1999)

By Dennis Lim (218) for Village Voice (8,525) on 05 Jul 2009

Stein's script is slack and tin-eared, too feeble to pass for satire, and inadequate even by lazy-pastiche standards…

Read Review

Review of The Cowboy Way (1994)

By Brandon K (542) on 22 Aug 2009

I cant believe I watched this, I think this, Man of the Year, and King Ralph are the worst movies I've seen in the theatre that weren't on…

Read Review

Review of Whatever Works (2009)

By Ann Hornaday (1,919) for Washington Post (9,851) on 25 Jun 2014

This toxic, contemptuous, unforgivably unfunny bagatelle finds Allen at his most misanthropically one-note…

Read Review

Review of Josie and the Pussycats (2001)

By Roger Ebert (5,190) for Chicago Sun-Times (7,580) on 19 Feb 2016

Josie and the Pussycats are not dumber than the Spice Girls, but they're as dumb as the Spice Girls, which is dumb enough…

Read Review

Review of The World of Henry Orient (1964)

By Daniel M (2,592) on 16 Jun 2012

If you had to pick one film which sums up everything wrong with 1960s comedies, your first choice would have to be The Millionairess…

Read Review

Review of Woman of the Year (1942)

By Stephannie R (2) on 05 Sep 2007

Looking back, this movie seems like the work of a male with a deep sense of paranoia from the feminist revolution. unpleasent to watch…

Read Review

Review of Love at First Bite (1979)

By Carlos I (1,309) on 16 Feb 2017

Yikes. That was painfully unfunny. The string of corny one-liners that don't land at all are almost cringeworthy…

Read Review

Review of The Prisoner of Second Avenue (1975)

By Steven M (1,153) on 10 Oct 2015

Trite and boring. Another waste of time from Doc Neil Simon. I will never understand his appeal…

Read Review

Review of That Darn Cat! (1965)

By Bosley Crowther (448) for The New York Times (9,847) on 20 Nov 1998

The color is good and Bobby Darin warbles a song at the start that may be amusing to humans but would probably fill Felix with disgust…

Read Review

More Reviews

Popular Movies Right Now

Three Thousand Years of Longing

2022

65%84 Reviews

Spider-Man: No Way Home

2021

79%458 Reviews

Purple Hearts

2022

56%11 Reviews

Parasite

2019

87%251 Reviews

The Menu

2022

70%145 Reviews

Oppenheimer

2023

85%310 Reviews

Ghostbusters: Afterlife

2021

66%228 Reviews

Hillbilly Elegy

2020

61%141 Reviews

The Equalizer

2014

69%994 Reviews

Talk to Me

2023

74%83 Reviews

Movies You Viewed Recently

Mistress America

2015

67%328 Reviews

Ex Machina

2015

79%1,167 Reviews

Rocketman

2019

76%168 Reviews

Visitor Q

2001

67%465 Reviews

TransSiberian

2008

66%647 Reviews

How She Move

2008

49%379 Reviews

Caffeine

2006

49%112 Reviews

Trumbo

2007

70%634 Reviews

Paris Je T'aime

2006

71%603 Reviews

The Expendables 2

2012

63%826 Reviews