Review of Mary Queen of Scots (2018) by Blake S — 27 Dec 2018

Mary Queen of Scots, Josie Rourke's first film, is more artistic than historic -- more modernly symbolic than factual. The film aptly captures the struggle of authoritative women in a world normally controlled by men -- a theme which is just as relevant today as it was in the 16th century.

The film also explores the dangers of rigid loyalty and allegiance fueled by tradition and orthodoxy, and through the sequential tragedies experienced by Mary, it artfully exposes the beautiful highs and ugly lows of human nature.

Saoirse Ronan's performance of Mary is haunting and powerful, and yet, the role is very much "Saoirse" (not too far removed from her other work). Margot Robbie's performance as Elizabeth is subdued and simple -- not nearly as commanding or notable as Cate Blanchett's performance as the virgin queen.

In fact, the most memorable thing about Robbie's Elizabeth is how she looks (hair, makeup, and costume); granted, Robbie has far less screen time than I expected. And after a slow first two acts (intermixed with choppy editing), the third act comes across as unjustly rushed -- especially for anyone unfamiliar with the history of Mary Stuart and Elizabeth I.

Final thoughts: while the film is overly dark, unpolished, and sentimental, it is still thought provoking and mildly entertaining.