Review of Kotch (1971) by Frankie A — 10 Sep 2008

First off, the director Jack Lemmon was one of the greatest actors of all time. This is the only movie he directed so from that POV alone its worth a watch.

Walter Matthau plays Kotch and he is restrained, affecting a character that loves life, wants to be involved and wants to engage with people. Very brief flashbacks show his relationship with his wife, that mirror the present-day action and its clear he has all his marbles and is an independent soul.

He tries to hold on to his relationship with his toddler grandson, and just can't gain the trust of his son and daughter in law. To help with young Duncan instead of Kotch, the parents find Deborah Winters' character Erica, who is brought in to help. Erica is young, trying to do the right things but finds herself very pregnant, and having to leave.

Kotch, who seems to be on the side of the young and defenseless, chooses to help out Erica rather than take up residence in a seniors home. He hits the road, tracks her down, and helps Erica bring her baby in to the world.

Matthau's character and everyone who watches this learns that Erica considers Kotch a part of the new baby's family, and shares her regret that Kotch never held her and touched her - which is the universal regret of many people. Pass the kleenex.

Deborah Winters plays a complex character part good kid, part free spirit, part practical mom to be. She is wholesome looking and even knits which softens up her predicament. The very best scenes are between Erica and Kotch and between Kotch and Duncan.

I think the film didn't need the story line of substance abuse of the daughter in law , but over all it is well worth watching to fully appreciate the great ending.