Review of Imitation of Life (1959) by Suzanne S — 24 Jul 2010
Not nearly as strong as the original, as glamour-girl Lana Turner makes her fortune as an actress, rather than by going into business with her maid, Juanita Moore. The relationship between the two women is much less problematic and easier to accept than in the original. As an employee, Moore would naturally live in the "servants' quarters" and take orders from Turner, regardless of race.
However, this change does allow the film to focus on daughter Piola, played by Susan Kohner, and racial prejudice to a degree that the original did not. Unfortunately, the film does not seriously challenge the social hierarchy of the day, and continues to suggest that true happiness can only be found through willing acceptance of one's place and calm resignation to one's fate.
On the other hand, the sexism is rampant. The film is a screed against working mothers, as Turner's focus on her career leads her to neglect and alienate her daughter Sandra Dee. Of course, given that Sandra Dee is her usual perky, annoying self, it's not much of a loss.
This review of Imitation of Life (1959) was written by Suzanne S on 24 Jul 2010.
Imitation of Life has generally received very positive reviews.
Was this review helpful?
