Review of I Wish (2011) by Jesse O — 13 Dec 2012

This is a very sweet and gentle movie that presents its child characters in a very believable fashion. I think what Hirozaku Koreeda did best was give these kids a certain sense of freedom to be, just what they are, kids.

Or at least creating an illusion that he gave them freedom. Because the kids are naturals and Koreeda handles his characters with respect and care, he simply lets you observes the lives of these kids and their lives and how their wishes are affected by the events of their own lives.

It is a very smart film and one that doesn't assume that its kid characters are idiots and that's refreshing to see. The characters are never infuriating and you understand their motivations for the things they feel the most need or want.

But I do think the pacing will certainly bother some people, it's got a deliberate pace but it is a rewarding experience ultimately. And I do think that a lot of people will also be bothered by the fact that not a lot seems to be happening in the film.

Not that the assessment is true. Just because a film is quieter and more observant, that doesn't mean that nothing is happening, it's just a more introspective film rather than a film where everything is explicitly stated.

So yea this is a lovely and gentle film and I'd definitely recommend it. It will test some peoples' patience but it is a rewarding film.