Review of Gods and Generals (2003) by Christopher S — 28 Nov 2007

"Gods and Generals" is a bizarre case, a schizophrenic film that features moments of high emotion and undeniable power, crossed with inexplicably drawn-out subplots and "quiet scenes".

This Civil War buff appreciates the wonderful degree of authenticity, and the film's battle scenes are top-notch - the battle of the two Irish Brigades at Fredericksburg is one of the most heart-wrenching moments on film, and the film's other battles are just as well-done.

But just when the film starts to pick up steam, irrelevant and poorly drawn subplots and supporting characters (Stonewall Jackson's relationship with a little Virginia girl) drag it down. Good acting, with Stephen Lang's fabulous performance as Stonewall Jackson being the highlight, and fabulous battle scenes which are much more cinematic and gripping than those in "Gettysburg", but overlong and overstuffed.

Worth a look though.