Cinafilm has over 5 million movie reviews and counting …

About Us
Contact Us
Sitemap
Follow us onCinafilm - Twitter Cinafilm - Pinterest

Last updated: 18 Jul 2026 at 16:41 UTC

Back to movie details

Forever My Girl (2018) - Critic Reviews - Page 2 of 2

21-40 of 40 Reviews

Sort by:

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Peter Hartlaub (620) for San Francisco Chronicle (7,630) on 19 Jan 2018

It’s a poorly made film, with rough edits, distracting staging and plot contrivances that can be predicted to the moment…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Christian Toto (897) for HollywoodInToto.com (350) on 19 Jan 2018

Is Forever My Girl formulaic? You betcha. Tell that to the lump in your throat…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Ryan Porter (13) for Toronto Star (3,601) on 18 Jan 2018

Rothe was a standout in last year's horror comedy Happy Death Day, but the Denver-born actor's performance here as Josie is as coolly bland…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Katie Walsh (1,279) for Chicago Tribune (6,211) on 18 Jan 2018

Forever My Girl doesn’t stray from the formula or do anything revolutionary…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Gary Thompson (1,554) for Philadelphia Daily News (1,596) on 18 Jan 2018

The movie also trumpets hometown values, and makes fun of the way Liam’s wealth and fame have insulated him from simple pleasures of small-town…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Kimber Myers (423) for The Playlist (3,871) on 18 Jan 2018

The country-fried romance written and directed by Bethany Ashton Wolf becomes a victim of self sabotage as it nears its (predictable) conclusion,…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Frank Scheck (1,741) for The Hollywood Reporter (7,050) on 18 Jan 2018

It's difficult to entirely resist the film's heartwarming portrait of decent people who genuinely care for each other and strive to do the…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Danny King (66) for Village Voice (8,525) on 18 Jan 2018

Wolf establishes only a half-formed idea of the decisions, fights, and silences that have shaped these characters’ lives, so the cast often…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Mark Dujsik (2,093) for Mark Reviews Movies (2,037) on 18 Jan 2018

[T]he movie is founded on a few fantasies: that Josie would basically wait for Liam, that the right woman can change a terrible guy, and that…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Bill Goodykoontz (2,123) for Arizona Republic (3,909) on 18 Jan 2018

Forever My Girl is a bad movie, pure and simple. And pure and simple is just how writer and director Bethany Ashton Wolf likes it…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Ella Taylor (978) for NPR (1,713) on 18 Jan 2018

The problem is not the well-worn plot or familiar characters, but the fact that Wolf adds no depth or complication to either that would make…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Alonso Duralde (1,351) for TheWrap (3,203) on 18 Jan 2018

Aficionados of Nicholas Sparks movies may swoon over this film’s distressed T-shirts and kudzu-choked back roads, but lovers of love stories…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Nell Minow (2,357) for Movie Mom (753) on 18 Jan 2018

Pretty people with pretty problems will always be playing on a screen somewhere, but this one is better suited for watching while folding laundry…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Derek Smith (382) for Slant Magazine (8,298) on 18 Jan 2018

Forever My Girl makes one wonder if Bethany Ashton Wolf actually thinks this is what true love is like…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Kim Hughes (164) for Original Cin (1,156) on 18 Jan 2018

Twee, yes, but Forever My Girl has plenty of heart and some solid performances. A journey not entirely without pleasure…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Rafer Guzman (1,080) for Newsday (2,345) on 18 Jan 2018

Just about anyone with a level head would see Forever My Girl as the story of a narcissist manipulating a naive doormat…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Joe Leydon (915) for Variety (12,700) on 18 Jan 2018

Forever My Girl is a sweet but slight romantic drama that got lost on its way to the Hallmark Channel — or, more likely, was rebuffed by…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Roger Moore (6,008) for Movie Nation (3,875) on 17 Jan 2018

The overarching problem is pacing and dramatic tension…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Jesse Hassenger (800) for The A.V. Club (5,644) on 17 Jan 2018

The movie isn’t as off-the-charts shameless as Sparks, but it lacks the Russian roulette death-guessing game to occupy viewers who get bored…

Review of Forever My Girl (2018)

By Kimberley Jones (866) for Austin Chronicle (7,653) on 17 Jan 2018

This bland romance doesn’t take its own advice. It’s all water, no whiskey…

1
2

Page 2 of 2

Next

More reviews of this movie:

Perhaps you were looking for:

Good Girl, Bad Girl (2006)

Gillian Vigman - Top 5 movies:

Jessica Rothe - Top 5 movies:

John Benjamin Hickey - Top 5 movies:

Movies you might like:

What a Girl Wants

2003

58%510 Reviews

2001

80%918 Reviews

2000

43%366 Reviews

1980

69%32 Reviews

2021

73%126 Reviews

1997

60%342 Reviews

Johnny Handsome

1989

62%51 Reviews

2005

79%875 Reviews

1990

68%584 Reviews

Eat Drink Man Woman

1994

81%368 Reviews

2000

46%189 Reviews

2000

65%444 Reviews

Share This Page

Share

Tweet

Popular Movies Right Now

Three Thousand Years of Longing

2022

65%84 Reviews

Blade Runner 2049

2017

80%2,332 Reviews

2014

81%1,229 Reviews

Hillbilly Elegy

2020

61%141 Reviews

2023

85%310 Reviews

2022

66%170 Reviews

2014

69%994 Reviews

Spider-Man: No Way Home

2021

79%458 Reviews

2017

71%1,218 Reviews

2021

58%19 Reviews

Movies You Viewed Recently

Forever My Girl

2018

64%115 Reviews

In the Valley of Elah

2007

71%723 Reviews

2001

76%328 Reviews

2016

44%851 Reviews

The Station Agent

2003

80%675 Reviews

Last Action Hero

1993

60%664 Reviews

The Croods: A New Age

2020

65%59 Reviews

New York, I Love You

2008

51%591 Reviews

Mr. Magorium's Wonder Emporium

2007

56%685 Reviews

Some Like It Hot

1939

78%616 Reviews

Get social with CinafilmFollow us for reviews of the latest moviesCinafilm - Twitter Cinafilm - Pinterest Cinafilm - RSS

© 2026 Cinafilm Internet Productions

Prime Video logo is a trademark of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates

Our website support team can be reached by email at [email protected], or by phoning +44 3300 431 396

Cinafilm IP, Office 12693, PO Box 15113, Birmingham, West Midlands, B2 2NJ, United Kingdom