Review of Dean Spanley (2008) by Ella H — 06 Jun 2010

"Dean Spanley" is based on a novel by Lord Dunsany, published in 1936. My interest in this film came from the fact that some time ago I read some collections of Dunsany's stories and was greatly impressed, particularly by the "Last Book of Wonder" collection- imaginative, subtly witty and extremely well-written.

"Dean Spanley" is set in the early years of the 20th century and concerns Young Fisk, played by Jeremy Northam, and his curmudgeonly father (Peter O'Toole). Their relationship is strained; Young Fisk's brother was killed in the Boer War and his mother died shortly afterwards. His father does not acknowledge any grief at these events, and is a seemingly mean-spirited individual, who keeps up a steady stream of withering and ill-tempered comment on any subject that occurs to him. The plot is set in motion when they meet Dean Spanley (Sam Neill), who is under the impression that he was a dog in a previous life, and whose character takes on some dog-like traits when he is given a certain drink. An unexpected link that arises between the Fisks and Dean Spanley provides the main focus of the film.

"Dean Spanley" is a most enjoyable film, it is extremely funny at times, but it has a tender charm, and an innocence, of its own. The acting is all good, but especially that of Sam Neill, who has the unenviable task of playing a clergyman who thinks he's a dog. This makes for considerable humour, but Neill also invests the character with a great dignity, seeming to convey some of the simplicity and nobility of character that we tend to associate with dogs. Ultimately this is a very touching film, understated but emotionally rich, an edifying experience for the viewer, and perfect in its own unassuming way.