Review of Colonel Redl (1985) by Alistair N — 21 Aug 2009
This film stands in the shade of the actor and director's previous collaboration on Mephisto. Redl is more complex and therefore less pure and arresting than the relatively simple story of Mephisto, it's aim to wide and scattergun to make the impact it desires. The irony of Redl being both promoted and then ruined for political reasons because he is an insider remains interesting, but Redl is a hard character to truly invest in, despite the fact we are clearly intended to, and his tragedy at the end is therefore less moving - and interesting - than it should be.
However, Brandauer is truly exceptional - why did he not have a better career in film? - carving every slice of Redl's complex, manufactured personaly with a loving skill. Very strong support from Niklas and Mueller Stahl as the men who both personally and professionally betray him and Szabo's direction is tight even if the length of the film is too much.
A thematic companion piece rather than a stand alone classic, but it has moments of inspiration.
This review of Colonel Redl (1985) was written by Alistair N on 21 Aug 2009.
Colonel Redl has generally received very positive reviews.
Was this review helpful?
