Review of Ballad of a Soldier (1959) by Scott H — 02 Oct 2008

This was a really good movie, wholesome and virtuous despite its Soviet context. Its value as a tool in the hands of Soviet propagandists is clear, but the story itself is above mere propaganda. It is a love story, and it could have been set in any nation.

The story follows a well mannered young soldier named Alyosha Skvortsov as he embarks on a mission of devotion to his mother. During the only combat scene, immediately after the narrator sets up the ballad, Alyosha manages to perform an act of bravery that earns him a six day leave. What any good boy would do with six days leave is to go home to fix his mother's leaky roof, right? Of course! Alyosha sets off only to be delayed by his good nature, kindheartedness, service-mindedness, and the rather heartbreaking fact that he falls in love with a young fellow traveler. The story is quite absorbing, simple as it may be, and I found it comfortably paced and beautifully composed. Rich scenery and careful composition made the view of Russia during WWII look quite beautiful, even the ugly parts. At the same time, there is a constant threat of ominous war, allusions to corruption, and a nod toward challenging circumstances. There is a tension all throughout too, for the viewer knows Alyosha's fate from the beginning, casting an urgency on his various exploits.

But the most important trait of this film, and plainly obvious, is the noble character of Alyosha. He's a model young man of selfless charm, even IF the writer was motivated by a worldview in moral contradiction. His smile is infecting, his devotion to others is inspiring. He is the dutiful youth serving his country, honest in admitting fear, generous in time and effort, and loving to a degree rarely seen anymore. Alyosha is a picture of naive goodness, which is ironically what causes him grief. His noble heart is a perfect example for a youngster so long as that youngster can decipher movie maker motives.