Review of An American Crime (2007) by Mark A — 08 Aug 2009

This was extremely hard to watch as Gertrude (Catherine Keener) perpetrated horrible abuse on the young, innocent boarder, Sylvia (Ellen Page). The narrative is driven by scenes from the trial with flashbacks to the abuse that were graphic enough that this viewer had to pause it to regain composure more than once.

Bradley Whitford, as prosecutor Leroy New, served as the narrator, and was a little less passionate than this tragedy cried out for, but also served as the voice of reason. Sad to think that in a time when small town neighbors knew your business that this torture was allowed to continue unchecked until it was too late for Sylvia.

Suberb acting by all. Even the supporting cast of children hit their marks superbly. Keener played the psychotic sadist with a detached intensity that was chilling. Ms. Page looked a little young for sixteen, but brought the required meekness and innocence to her role.

A definite cautionary tale and another meaty role for Ms. Page who is fast becoming another of my favorite actors. This one will haunt.