Review of All Quiet on the Western Front (1930) by Cameron J — 06 Mar 2015

When I saw the TV adaptation, I thought "This is a fantastic, original and moving story, but if it wasn't so dull like it is in this version, it could have been a sensational cinematic work of art." Now, we get to the true, widely acclaimed classic version and though it works out most of the kinks when it come to pacing, the emotional resonanse is a little bit fuzzier. Of course, that doesn't mean that the film is completely stripped of compelliness, as it still boasts some sharp emotional impact. Still, before we get to that, let's discuss the flaws behind the film. These flaws include a lack of development, slow spots, some poorly-aged performances and a bit too much pace-slowing at points.

Still, through all of its flaws, the story is very original and moving and if they had worked on the emotional resonanse and some other elements, they could have made it a magnificent tale. Still, as it stands, the film is quite compelling, being carried by Lewis Milestone's direction and a deal of strong acting spots that have stood the test of time. Other strengths include very good production designs, solid effects and great war sequences. As for the film's anti-war message, it's not preachy, but still notable enough to be effective. This film emphasizes the harshness of the battlefield and even though the Wartime struggles have certainly been smoothed down significantly over these almost 100 years, the message still holds up and has you feeling for those who have fought and wondering about those who are fighting now.

Ultimately, though it may not hit home as hard as the still inferior second adaptation, Lewis Milestone's classic "All Quiet on the Western Front" is a mostly well-crafted mini-epic, as well as a moving portrait on the struggles of those who risked their lives on the battlefield. Real quick, why does no one try to do a German accent? ...I don't have a punchline, I'm just asking.