Review of A Star Is Born (1954) by Nathan G — 01 Dec 2007

In my opinion, the best picture of Garland's adult career. Riveting.

This review of A Star Is Born (1954) was written by Nathan G on 01 Dec 2007.

A Star Is Born has generally received very positive reviews.

Was this review helpful?

Yes

More reviews of this movie:

A Star Is Born (1954) Movie Reviews (285)
A Star Is Born (1954) Critic Reviews (16)
A Star Is Born (1954) User Reviews (269)

More Reviews of A Star Is Born

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Mark L (1,544) on 09 Jun 2014

I never saw Grace Kelly in The Country Girl, but she must have been pretty dog gone good if she beat the uncanny performance by Garland in…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Les G (11) on 09 Jan 2015

This is a very good movie. The first time I watched it I thought it was good. Subsequent viewings made me realize it was great…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Alden S (433) on 18 Jul 2017

10 out of 10: They take the same story as the first and made it colorful and well shot. It also features amazing performances and great looking sets…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Logan M (1,902) on 03 Jul 2017

Every scene, every song, every piece of set design is sensational and Judy Garland is exceptionally stunning in the lead of this showbiz classic…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Matt H (2,287) on 18 Aug 2013

Possibly the most adapted storyline…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Bitash (86) on 11 Jun 2020

Although I already was familiar with the story line and how things will end and I had seen other versions of this movie, this one took me by…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Allen G (306) on 19 Jan 2019

Too long, and hard to understand why the character who wants to be a singer is happy to be a movie star into the bargain, but engaging performances…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Korte Y (2) on 03 Nov 2018

Horrendous editing Baffled at thw high ratings for this 3 hour trudge…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Carlos M (2,069) on 08 Oct 2018

Forget the 1937 version, this is a much superior remake that does right everything (except for that awful last line) that the original film…

Read Review

Review of A Star Is Born (1954)

By Virginia Graham (38) for The Spectator (1,162) on 02 Oct 2018

From this almost traditional mush, Moss Hart, basing his script on an older one by Dorothy Parker, Alan Campbell and Robert Carson, has written…

Read Review

More reviews of this movie

Reviews of Similar Movies

Review of West Side Story (1961)

By Dusty L (218) on 29 Mar 2015

I hate musicals. I was told this is a classic and the best musical ever, so I watched it. I still hate musicals…

Read Review

Review of Nowhere (1997)

By Shane M (526) on 01 Jan 2004

This movie is like a bad acid trip....scene after scene of vile, disgusting images with no redeeming qualities whatsoever…

Read Review

Review of Inland Empire (2006)

By Larryh. (9) on 04 May 2007

I love David Lynch. I am a follower of Lynch. But Inland Empire was 3 hours of abysmal film…

Read Review

Review of The Holiday (2006)

By Pete Hammond (936) for Maxim (189) on 13 Dec 2006

We can all figure out where this thing is going but getting there is the prime attraction here…

Read Review

Review of Chicago (2002)

By Beth Accomando (509) for KPBS.org (509) on 14 Mar 2003

Rob Marshall's style is to make everything relentlessly brassy and fake, and his Chicago simply looks like a filmed stage play…

Read Review

Review of Bedazzled (2000)

By Kublay0880 (49) on 19 Dec 2012

You can get a few good laughs of this movie (thanks to the script), but from that to have scores above 6 out of 10 it's crazy, Fraser as always,…

Read Review

Review of A Chorus Line (1985)

By Bryan K (485) on 26 Jul 2014

This movie would make you NOT see the live version. It was a terrible disappointment…

Read Review

Review of Fahrenheit 451 (1966)

By Alexander N (134) on 03 Jun 2014

It had its moments, but far too few of them. Overall, very dated, very slow, and very boring. Most of all, boring. Having trouble sleeping…

Read Review

Review of The Vanishing (1993)

By Robert I (1,833) on 05 Dec 2012

Skip this & watch the original one again, Although I was expecting the ridiculous happy-ending but it was still more ridiculous than I thought,…

Read Review

Review of Lemming (2005)

By Rosemary L (18) on 01 Feb 2009

This story looked really interesting and intriguing but ended up going nowhere...not recommended…

Read Review

More Reviews

Popular Movies Right Now

A Simple Favor

2018

69%617 Reviews

Alien: Covenant

2017

61%1,909 Reviews

Babylon

2022

68%144 Reviews

Nope

2022

68%181 Reviews

No Hard Feelings

2023

65%90 Reviews

Mission: Impossible - Dead Reckoning Part One

2023

79%186 Reviews

Blade Runner 2049

2017

80%2,332 Reviews

Purple Hearts

2022

56%11 Reviews

Dawn of the Planet of the Apes

2014

79%1,167 Reviews

The Batman

2022

75%430 Reviews