Review of A History of Violence (2005) by Rostokova — 09 Oct 2005
A History of Violence is a simple film whos deadpan delivery, extreme violence and sexual aggression have elevated its critical status. The setup is simple and tailored to character development rather than narrative revelation, yet little depth in character is accrued during the film's course.
Despite a fine performance by Viggo Mortensen, the script is far too spare in its treatment of his character, and lacks the psychogical tension and unease of Cronenberg's excellent Dead Ringers. The central implication that man can't change his nature, only suppress it, is explored superficially and mostly for gratification.
Equally the ending's suggestion that violence may often be integral to the creation of the American dream is certainly subversive, but warrants further examination, rather than genre neatness. Blue Velvet also showed there was something dark beyond the picket fence; but it was assured, poetic and contained a subconscious as well as visceral threat.
In comparison 'History' seems slight and hollow, its deadpan, off-beat delivery just a distraction from its vacuity.
This review of A History of Violence (2005) was written by Rostokova on 09 Oct 2005.
A History of Violence has generally received very positive reviews.
Was this review helpful?
