Review of Winchester '73 (1950) by Sarfaraz A — 14 Aug 2012

James Stewart's greatest western and one of the five all time best.

This review of Winchester '73 (1950) was written by Sarfaraz A on 14 Aug 2012.

Winchester '73 has generally received very positive reviews.

Was this review helpful?

Yes

More reviews of this movie:

More Reviews of Winchester '73

Review of Winchester '73 (1950)

By Cody C (666) on 02 Apr 2016

Definitely my favourite Anthony Mann Western I've seen so far…

Read Review

Review of Winchester '73 (1950)

By Frédéric I (160) on 30 Oct 2009

I'll have to change my usual I don't like Westerns stance to I don't LOVE Westerns, but most of them are okay…

Read Review

Review of Winchester '73 (1950)

By Brian P (1,844) on 07 Apr 2012

Beautiful Western with Jimmy Stewart doing his best (low-key) acting, and he doesn't have to carry the whole picture himself…

Read Review

Review of Winchester '73 (1950)

By Paul J (1,190) on 23 Jun 2011

Another fine pairing of Mann and Stewart. Simple yet ingenious premise. Whizzes by like a bullet. Extremely tight, done to perfection…

Read Review

Review of Winchester '73 (1950)

By John E (845) on 15 May 2011

Watching a lovable American everyman like Jimmy Stewart eschew his aw shucks, humble pie demeanor and just go balls-out in a movie is compelling…

Read Review

Review of Winchester '73 (1950)

By Jose Luis M (587) on 29 Nov 2014

141128: Very enjoyable black and white film. Neat story and good characters. Not often do I raise ratings but I did here…

Read Review

Review of Winchester '73 (1950)

By Josh R (768) on 20 Apr 2012

One of my very favorite Westerns and Jimmy Stewart films…

Read Review

Review of Winchester '73 (1950)

By Jared H (400) on 12 Sep 2011

Throw in a MacGuffin (which in this case, a Winchester rifle model 1873) into a Western and you'll get a very refreshing and original Western…

Read Review

Review of Winchester '73 (1950)

By Liz K (234) on 13 Oct 2012

Fantastic movie. Jimmy Stewart made some of the most interesting Westerns…

Read Review

Review of Winchester '73 (1950)

By Cale H (12) on 22 Jan 2011

Not only one of my favorite westerns (tied with Once Upon a time in the West), but my absolutely favorite Jimmy Stewart movie…

Read Review

More reviews of this movie

Reviews of Similar Movies

Review of High Plains Drifter (1973)

By Joel M (772) on 13 Jan 2010

The music that is supposed to make everything supernatural is kind of bad - the effect it is going for I appreciate, but the music is just…

Read Review

Review of Shane (1953)

By John S (2,711) on 29 Aug 2012

Didn't like it. Alan Ladd is pretty good as Shane, but the story is to predictable and it could have been told in about an hour…

Read Review

Review of The Man From Snowy River II (1988)

By Eva E (18) on 05 Apr 2009

Switching actors in the sequel rarely bodes well, and this movie is a case in point: Kirk Douglas' star performance from the first film is…

Read Review

Review of She Wore a Yellow Ribbon (1949)

By John W (1,851) on 01 Feb 2007

A long drawn out crass depiction of unreal soldier-boys taming the west…

Read Review

Review of Oklahoma! (1955)

By Martin D (1,305) on 12 Jun 2007

Look, it's a musical, and I just don't like them…

Read Review

Review of My Darling Clementine (1946)

By Bonnie D (27) on 25 Mar 2008

I am such a killjoy. This movie was horrible. It takes a TRUE story about the Earps and Clantons, fictionalizes it (why…

Read Review

Review of The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962)

By Brody M (674) on 22 Apr 2011

Not as good as I heard or thought it was gonna be.Even with all the big names, (It even had Uncle Jessie from Dukes Of Hazzard in a small role)…

Read Review

Review of The Outlaw Josey Wales (1976)

By E A (22) on 02 Oct 2014

A really dumb shoot-em-up western, complete with gatling guns. Hard to believe that this is from the same director as Flags of Our Fathers…

Read Review

Review of The Ox-Bow Incident (1943)

By Emanuel Levy (2,948) for EmanuelLevy.Com (2,771) on 20 Feb 2008

One of the first probes of mob lynch, Wellman's grim, uncompromising expose was critically acclaimed but failed, perhaps because it was released…

Read Review

Review of Ace High (1968)

By A A (501) on 10 Oct 2007

Disappointingly slow & uninvolving spag western. Wallach tries to rehash his Tuco character from GB&U…

Read Review

More Reviews

Popular Movies Right Now

The Judge

2014

67%866 Reviews

Deadpool

2016

78%1,333 Reviews

Ghostbusters: Afterlife

2021

66%228 Reviews

No Time to Die

2021

74%254 Reviews

Past Lives

2023

84%62 Reviews

Fifty Shades of Grey

2015

43%1,173 Reviews

Mission: Impossible - Dead Reckoning Part One

2023

79%186 Reviews

John Wick: Chapter 4

2023

78%170 Reviews

Nope

2022

68%181 Reviews

Top Gun: Maverick

2022

82%272 Reviews

Movies You Viewed Recently

Winchester '73

1950

78%124 Reviews

American Graffiti

1973

79%734 Reviews

So I Married an Axe Murderer

1993

61%453 Reviews

The Ottoman Lieutenant

2017

57%104 Reviews

Free Jimmy

2006

61%97 Reviews

Admiral

2015

68%12 Reviews

Downton Abbey

2019

69%67 Reviews

The Magic Sword

1962

38%36 Reviews

The Road to El Dorado

2000

66%695 Reviews

Keep 'Em Flying

1941

62%6 Reviews