Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924) by Mark F — 16 Oct 2007

This film simply does not age. Keaton is the one bona fide genius of film comedy.

This review of Sherlock Jr. (1924) was written by Mark F on 16 Oct 2007.

Sherlock Jr. has generally received very positive reviews.

Was this review helpful?

Yes

More reviews of this movie:

More Reviews of Sherlock Jr.

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Greg W (4,011) on 06 Jun 2014

What you have here is essentially a silent movie from the time when modern comedy was born…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Derek A (174) on 21 Jan 2014

An enjoyable surprise! Very impressive and very funny…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Fallon B (145) on 16 Apr 2016

Far and wide legend Buster Keaton's best feature film, however only being 45m long. In short Sherlock Jr…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Steve G (1,301) on 20 Mar 2017

- This was my 2nd time seeing this and I introduced it to my 6 yr old Niece who laughed her head off…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Matt M (2,511) on 26 Dec 2013

Keaton reaches slapstick perfection with his tale of a film projectionist turned amateur sleuth…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Alex S (2,786) on 07 Aug 2014

It may not be as good as The General, but it'll still keep you smiling the whole way through…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Simon D (1,648) on 12 Sep 2015

You might not expect the world greatest detective in the middle of a Buster Keaton silent movie but here he is, although he is apparently Sherlock…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Pierluigi P (335) on 10 Aug 2013

Hilarious and physically impressive gags. Keaton's imagination was boundless…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Dave Kehr (1,442) for Chicago Reader (7,190) on 28 May 2015

Keaton's appreciation of the formal paradoxes of the medium is astounding; his observations on the relationship between film and the subconscious…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Jr. (1924)

By Esteban G (391) on 05 May 2014

We are lost! He is sending for the world's greatest detective - Sherlock Jr…

Read Review

More reviews of this movie

Reviews of Similar Movies

Review of Son of the Mask (2005)

By Willie Waffle (1,383) for WaffleMovies.com (1,380) on 06 Mar 2005

How far down the Hollywood food chain do you have to go before you get stuck with Jamie Kennedy as the star of your movie…

Read Review

Review of The Cat in the Hat (2003)

By Michael Atkinson (678) for Village Voice (8,525) on 21 Jun 2004

Comes scarily close to being the most unendurable Hollywood creation of the last dozen years…

Read Review

Review of The Medallion (2003)

By Marc Savlov (2,019) for Austin Chronicle (7,653) on 01 Dec 2015

One of the Peking Opera-trained superstar's most mediocre films, rivaling last year’s God-awful The Tuxedo for sheer messy filmmaking…

Read Review

Review of Sherlock Holmes (2009)

By Bryans. (6) on 05 Jan 2010

I would love to review the whole of this movie but I honestly don't know if it improves after the first hour…

Read Review

Review of Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa (2008)

By Walter Chaw (1,360) for Film Freak Central (1,643) on 09 Nov 2008

There aren't very many alternatives right at this moment, so expect it to make money out of proportion with its quality…

Read Review

Review of In the Heat of the Night (1967)

By Adi B (55) on 25 Jul 2012

Again, aged badly and, consequently, I was offended enough by the ridiculous sexism that I couldn't watch past the thirty minute mark…

Read Review

Review of No Escape (1994)

By Kiefer F (44) on 22 Nov 2009

Liotta is strong here, and Lance Heinreksen is having a ball, but the movie never took off for me…

Read Review

Review of The Death and Life of Bobby Z (2007)

By Ruiz M (50) on 01 Jun 2013

Paul Walker still making movies apparently. May as well put Hayden Christensen in it too. Terrible…

Read Review

Review of George of the Jungle (1997)

By Michael Dequina (1,684) for TheMovieReport.com (1,582) on 01 Jan 2000

At the media screening, the guy sitting behind me could be heard loudly snoring during the third act. We should all be so lucky…

Read Review

Review of Guest House Paradiso (1999)

By Stan H (36) on 04 Sep 2017

Sorry Rik and Ade love you guys, but this movie blows not many laughs in it…

Read Review

More Reviews

Popular Movies Right Now

Three Thousand Years of Longing

2022

65%84 Reviews

Fifty Shades of Grey

2015

43%1,173 Reviews

Mad Max: Fury Road

2015

83%1,378 Reviews

Where the Crawdads Sing

2022

63%92 Reviews

The Menu

2022

70%145 Reviews

Babylon

2022

68%144 Reviews

Joker

2019

81%299 Reviews

Ghostbusters: Afterlife

2021

66%228 Reviews

Love

2015

54%174 Reviews

John Wick: Chapter 4

2023

78%170 Reviews